The brand's tester kit,
$16

Shave Like
a Prospector

File this under stuff that gets us every time (quality ingredients, an earnest mission and good packaging), the Prospector Co. grooming line out of Savannah, Georgia. According to the Southern gents behind the brand, it's "a line for men who seek purpose and forethought in their skin and shave products, with formulas for pre- and post-shaving, unshaven scruff to a beard gone wild." The small-batch bottles range from a moisturizing beard oil to a refreshing alcohol-free aftershave, to a woody, vitamin E-enriched shave oil that requires no shaving cream at all. The simple, all-natural ingredients make for effective and soothing products, gentle enough for sensitive skin. But the old-timey look of the stuff ensures you look like a tough guy.

K.C. Atwood Aftershave,
$18

Burrough's Beard Oil,
from $18