Sales & Deals

The Best Reviewed Baking Sheets

'Tis the season for baking cookies. And good cookies require a proper cookie sheet. A simple kitchen staple, it might be okay to dismiss them as all the same. But the better ones all but guarantee better results. So whether you're baking a batch of chocolate chunks, roasting some winter vegetables or prepping a pan of nachos, make sure your pan is built to last. Here are the best ones on Amazon, according to real world reviews.

Nordic Ware Commercial
Baker Sheet

Nordic Ware Commercial
Baker Sheet

4 1/2 stars

/ 3,549 reviews

“You won't find heavier duty pans. And the size means two fit perfectly in the oven. They are much easier to clean than one huge pan, plus they're easier to store inside your cabinets.”

$22.35 at Amazon

USA Pan Aluminized
Steel Half Sheet

USA Pan Aluminized
Steel Half Sheet

4 1/2 stars

/ 700 reviews

“The corrugated surface and silicone coating means that absolutely nothing sticks to these things. I don't even use parchment paper anymore. But hand wash them to protect the coating.”

$37.99 at Amazon

Rachel Ray Nonstick
Bakeware Sheet

Rachel Ray Nonstick
Bakeware Sheet

4 1/2 stars

/ 1,358 reviews

“The deeper sides and silicone handles mean these are foolproof. And the serious nonstick coating makes for easy release of food and quick cleanup too.”

$29.99 at Amazon

Advertisement