It’s Time to Swap Out Your Pillow

It’s Time
to Swap Out Your Pillow

Do it now and
start sleeping better

Words by

The Valet. staff

Photography by

Courtesy

Published

April 4, 2022

Updated

February 29, 2024

Note

Items featured in this story are independently selected by the editorial team. Purchasing via our links may earn Valet. a portion of the sale, which helps fund our editorial mission.

A good night’s sleep is paramount to your overall health and well-being. And like mattresses, your pillow plays a major role in the quality of your sleep. A new pillow is a fairly easy investment—much cheaper than replacing your mattress—that offers a big payoff. That is, if you know which pillow is right for you. The National Sleep Foundation recommends replacing your pillow every one to two years. How do you know when it's time for a new pillow? “Fold it in half and see if it stays that way,” they say. “If it does, it's time for a new one.” Besides, if you've been using simple, throwaway pillows from a big box store, you're missing out. There are better options. And while an old school down pillow is still one of the most popular, there are also a few fantastic alternative options you may want to try out (like cooling pillows). Herewith, the best options our team of troubled sleepers found.

The Best Pillows
for Troubled Sleepers

Best Overall

Memory-foam pillows can be ideal for all types of sleepers, but most are too dense and tend to retain heat. This clever version is filled with a shredded, nontoxic memory foam that holds its loft while allowing air to circulate. Plus, you can remove or add filling at home to create your own perfect height. A bamboo-derived stay-cool fabric cover is also hypoallergenic and dust mite resistant, which is ideal for allergy sufferers or germaphobes who want the ultimate comfort.

Original Loft pillow,
$75 by Coop Home

The Down
Gold Standard

A classic goose down pillow still reigns supreme in terms of moldable comfort and a light, fluffy luxurious feel. However, some sleepers complain of insufficient support and excessive sinkage around the head and neck. Brooklinen's popular down pillow is a standout because it comes in three different constructions (plush, mid-plush and firm). Filled with ethically-sourced Canadian down, they're also a bargain at this price point.

Down pillow,
from ~~$119~~ / $101.15 by Brooklinen

Parachute Down Alternative Side Sleeper Pillow

Best for
Side Sleepers

Designed specifically for side and back sleepers, Parachute's medium-density down alternative pillow offers unparalleled support and retains its shape after you apply weight to it. That's all thanks to a 3.5 inch gusset designed to take the strain off your neck and shoulders while you rest. But the fluffy and 100% hypoallergenic down alternative fill keeps it from feeling too dense, which is often a problem with pillows made for side sleepers.

Down alternative side sleeper pillow,
$110 by Parachute

Best for
Stomach Sleepers

If you sleep on your stomach, you need a pillow with slightly less filling. These allow you to breathe comfortably and ensure your neck isn't strained. Saatva's clever pillow-in-pillow design helps promote spinal alignment for stomach sleepers, with a unique three-layer construction, that includes a cotton cover, an outer layer, and a bouncy shredded latex core. You can remove the core for a lower loft but the gusseted shape resists flattening.

Latex pillow,
from $165 by Saatva

Best for
Neck Pain

When you're looking for a problem-solving pillow to tackle genuine neck and shoulder pain, you can't go wrong with Tempur-Pedic. This pillow has been around for a while and stood the test of time because it works. The ergonomic shape elevates and supports the neck while cradling the head. It's available in three shapes so you can get the perfect contour for your neck, but know that it fits somewhat loosely in standard pillowcases and that it's sometimes deemed too firm by some.

Tempur-Neck pillow,
from $119 by Tempur-Pedic

For Adjustable
Support

We first experienced buckwheat pillows in a Japanese hotel, and while they're firmer than you might be used to, they have serious benefits. For instance, if you're a multi-position sleeper, the shape-shifting qualities of of these buckwheat hull-filled pillows, like this one from Hullo, allows for the pillow to easily conform to your shape and hold their position around your head. Plus they stay nice and cool. But like all buckwheat pillows, it makes a subtle rustling noise (like a beanbag) when you shift.

Buckwheat pillow,
$109 by Hullo

Keep Them Clean

Board-certified allergist-immunologist Ryan Steele, D.O. recommends washing your pillowcases (and sheets) once a week using the hottest setting you can to kill any and all microbes and allergens. This also washes away any skin cells, sweat, oil and drool that’s accumulated over the week.

Extend the Life
of Your Pillow

If you want your pillow to last longer (and why wouldn’t you?), experts suggest getting a washable, zippered cover that goes under your regular pillowcase. This will protect the pillow from dirt, dust and other gunk that can attract dust mites and cause allergies and acne.

The Smart Way
to Start Your Day

The Daily Valet. is your cheat sheet to what's happening, what's cool and what's making headlines. It's your secret to being the most interesting man in the room.

It’s Time to Swap Out Your Pillow

It’s Time to Swap Out Your Pillow

Words by

Photography by

Published

Updated

Note

The Best Pillows for Troubled Sleepers

Best Overall

The Down Gold Standard

Best for Side Sleepers

Best for Stomach Sleepers

Best for Neck Pain

For Adjustable Support

Keep Them Clean

Keep Them Clean

Extend the Life of Your Pillow

The Smart Way to Start Your Day

More on The Bedroom

Cooler Sleep Is Better Sleep

I Bought a Cooling Pillow and It Changed My Life

Upgrade Your Sheets and You Upgrade Your Life

The Most Important Piece in Your Bedroom

It’s Time
to Swap Out Your Pillow

The Best Pillows
for Troubled Sleepers

The Down
Gold Standard

Best for
Side Sleepers

Best for
Stomach Sleepers

Best for
Neck Pain

For Adjustable
Support

Extend the Life
of Your Pillow

The Smart Way
to Start Your Day

More on
The Bedroom

Cooler Sleep
Is Better Sleep

I Bought a Cooling Pillow
and It Changed My Life

Upgrade Your Sheets
and You Upgrade Your Life

The Most Important Piece
in Your Bedroom